All resources

Customer Reviews on Research Supply Sites

Reviews that describe personal use or results become your marketing once they are on your site. What the FTC says about reviews, how to moderate fairly, and when to turn reviews off.

Illustration for Customer Reviews on Research Supply Sites

A customer review that describes personal use, effects or results is a marketing claim once it appears on your site, even though a customer wrote it. For a research-use-only supplier, that kind of review says exactly what your labels say the product is not for. You have two workable choices: turn product reviews off, or moderate them under a written policy that you apply the same way to positive and negative reviews.

Whichever you choose, some practices are off the table entirely: writing or buying reviews, rewarding only positive ones, and hiding honest negative ones. This guide covers why, and how to handle the reviews you already have.

Why a customer review counts as your marketing

The FTC's guidance on endorsements describes an endorsement as an advertising message that consumers are likely to believe reflects the opinions of someone other than the advertiser. A review you choose to display on your product page fits that description. The same guidance says endorsements cannot be used to make claims that the marketer could not legally make itself. In other words, if you could not say it in your own product description, a review on your page should not say it for you.

The FTC's advertising guidance for small businesses adds that customer testimonials usually are not enough to support health or safety claims. A review describing results is not evidence of anything, and on a research supply site it should not be there in the first place.

Reviews that cause problems on a research supply site usually fall into these categories:

  • Descriptions of personal use, or use on a pet.
  • Descriptions of results, effects or changes in the reviewer.
  • Comparisons with medicines or branded products.
  • Advice to other customers about how to use or prepare a product.
  • Rating fields that invite the same content, such as stars for effectiveness or results.

Option one: turn product reviews off

For many research suppliers, this is the simplest and cleanest choice. A buyer evaluating a research material needs the specification, documentation and lot information, not other customers' opinions. If you turn reviews off:

  • Disable reviews in your store platform and in any review plugin or widget.
  • Remove existing reviews from public pages, including imported reviews and review snippets in your theme.
  • Remove star ratings from product structured data so they stop appearing in search results.
  • Stop automated emails that ask customers to leave a product review.

You can still ask customers for private feedback on ordering, delivery, packaging and support. That helps you run the business without publishing anything.

Option two: moderate under a written policy

If you keep reviews, decide what you publish before you start moderating, write it down and apply it evenly. The FTC's guide for businesses that feature online reviews is a useful reference here, and you should speak to a qualified lawyer about your own policy.

Write the content rules first

List the kinds of content you do not publish: the categories above, along with content you would exclude anyway, such as personal information, abuse or reviews unrelated to the product or service. The FTC's guide says to clearly and conspicuously disclose how you collect, process and display reviews, so publish a short version of these rules near your reviews.

Apply them the same way to good and bad reviews

The FTC's guide says not to subject negative reviews to greater scrutiny, and to publish all genuine reviews without excluding negative ones. In practice: a five-star review that describes personal use is not published. A one-star review about slow shipping is published. Your rules decide, not the star rating.

The FTC's endorsement guidance also says that holding all reviews for the same reasonable period before posting is acceptable, but delaying only negative reviews could give a biased picture. If you check reviews before they go live, check all of them.

Do not edit reviews to change their meaning

The FTC's guide says not to edit reviews to alter the message. If a review breaks your rules, do not cut out the problem sentence and publish the rest. Decline the whole review and, if you can, tell the reviewer which rule it broke and that they are welcome to submit a review about their ordering experience instead.

Record each decision

Keep a record of every review you decline: date, review text, the rule it broke and who decided. If anyone asks whether your moderation is even-handed, the record answers the question.

Practices that are never acceptable

The FTC has announced a final rule on the use of consumer reviews and testimonials. According to the FTC's announcement, the rule addresses, among other things:

  • Fake reviews, including reviews from people who do not exist, AI-generated reviews and reviews from people with no real experience of the business or product.
  • Offering compensation or incentives for reviews that express a particular sentiment, whether that condition is stated or implied.
  • Reviews by company insiders, such as officers and managers, that do not clearly disclose their connection to the business.
  • Websites the business controls that are presented as independent reviewers.
  • Suppressing negative reviews through threats or intimidation, or claiming that the reviews shown represent all or most reviews when negative ones were suppressed.
  • Buying or selling fake followers or views to misrepresent influence.

The FTC says the rule lets it seek civil penalties against knowing violators. Separately, its endorsement guidance says that if a customer received a free or discounted product in return for a review, that connection should be disclosed, and that you cannot make an incentive depend on the review being positive.

Reviews and testimonials outside your site

You cannot control what people write on third-party platforms or in their own social posts. You can control what you repeat. Do not quote, embed, screenshot or link to reviews that describe use or results, whether on your site, in emails or in ads. The same applies to testimonials gathered through partners; see affiliate and influencer programs for research suppliers and email marketing rules for online stores.

Cleaning up an existing review section

  1. Export every published review, including ones on product variants and old or archived products.
  2. Read each one against your written rules, or remove them all if you are turning reviews off.
  3. Check where review content appears outside product pages: homepage carousels, banners, structured data and emails.
  4. Rewrite review request emails so they ask about ordering, delivery and documentation, not about how a product worked.
  5. Record what you removed and when.

Old blog posts and landing pages often quote reviews too. Our guide to auditing old blog posts covers that sweep, and claims to remove from a research supply store lists the wording to look for.

How this fits with the rest of your compliance work

Reviews are one more place your store describes its products, so they belong in the same routine as product pages and policies. Claddr's weekly monitoring checks product pages, policies and checkout copy against your compliance profile and flags the exact line with a suggested fix. You decide what to change, and new reviews still need a person to read them as they arrive. See how Claddr works.

Sources

  1. 01FTC: FTC's Endorsement Guides: What People Are Askingwww.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/ftcs-endorsement-guides-what-people-are-asking
  2. 02FTC: Federal Trade Commission Announces Final Rule Banning Fake Reviews and Testimonialswww.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2024/08/federal-trade-commission-announces-final-rule-banning-fake-reviews-testimonials
  3. 03FTC: Featuring Online Customer Reviews: A Guide for Platformswww.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/featuring-online-customer-reviews-guide-platforms
  4. 04FTC: Advertising FAQs: A Guide for Small Businesswww.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/advertising-faqs-guide-small-business