Export controls are government rules on sending certain goods, software and technology to other countries, and on supplying certain people and organizations. In the United States, the Commerce Department's Bureau of Industry and Security (BIS) administers the Export Administration Regulations (EAR). Whether a shipment needs a license can depend on what the item is, where it is going, who will receive it and what it will be used for.
If you ship research products to buyers in other countries, you need to understand the basic questions, know where BIS publishes its guidance and know when to get help. This page is general information, not legal advice. Speak to a qualified lawyer, a licensed customs broker or a trade compliance specialist about your products and destinations.
What export controls cover
BIS describes its role as regulating exports and reexports of dual-use items: goods, software and technologies that have both commercial and military uses. The EAR is not limited to dual-use items, though. BIS's classification guidance explains that items subject to the EAR but not described on its control list are designated EAR99, so ordinary commercial products can still fall within the rules.
BIS treats commodities, software and technology all as items. If you supply technical documents or software alongside a physical product, those may need to be considered too.
Terms you will meet
- Commerce Control List (CCL). The list of items BIS controls, organized by category and product group.
- ECCN. An Export Control Classification Number. BIS describes it as a five-character code: the first character is a number from 0 to 9 for the broad category, the second a letter from A to E for the product group.
- EAR99. The designation for items subject to the EAR that are not described on the CCL. BIS says EAR99 items do not need a license in most situations, but may need one if they are going to a prohibited or restricted end user, end use or destination.
- Reexport. BIS describes a reexport as shipping or transmitting an item subject to the EAR from one foreign country to another. It can also include releasing controlled technology or source code in one foreign country to a national of another.
- License exception. An authorization described in Part 740 of the EAR that can allow some exports without a license, under stated conditions.
The questions that decide whether a license is needed
BIS's licensing guidance is organized around a short series of questions. Working through them for each product and destination is the core of any export check:
- Is the item, or the activity, subject to the EAR?
- How is the item classified: under a specific ECCN, or as EAR99?
- Where is it going? BIS's country guidance covers the Commerce Country Chart and country groups.
- Who will receive it, including any party in the middle of the transaction?
- What will it be used for?
- If a license would otherwise be needed, does a license exception apply?
Classifying what you sell
BIS lists three ways to find an item's classification:
- Ask the manufacturer, producer or developer of the item for its ECCN.
- Classify it yourself. BIS says this requires a technical understanding of the item and familiarity with how ECCNs are structured.
- Ask BIS for an official classification through its SNAP-R system, under section 748.3 of the EAR.
BIS also warns that ECCNs can change over time, so check classifications against the current CCL. A simple product classification record helps: for each product, note the classification, where it came from, who checked it and when. Do not assume a product is EAR99 because it is sold for laboratory research. Make the check and record it.
End users and end uses
BIS explains that license requirements can depend on who receives an item and how it will be used, not only on its classification and destination. These restrictions can apply to EAR99 items as well as to items on the CCL, and generally cover a listed party in any role in the transaction, not just the final recipient. BIS maintains several lists of parties of concern:
- Entity List. Parties BIS reasonably believes are involved in activities contrary to U.S. national security or foreign policy interests.
- Unverified List. Parties whose bona fides BIS could not verify.
- Military End-User List. BIS notes this list is not exhaustive, so exporters still need their own due diligence.
- Denied Persons List. Individuals and entities that have been denied export privileges.
BIS also points exporters to the Consolidated Screening List, which brings together lists maintained by the Departments of Commerce, State and the Treasury in one search. Know-your-customer basics for B2B suppliers covers screening international buyers as part of your wider buyer checks.
Red flags BIS asks exporters to notice
BIS publishes "Know Your Customer" guidance with a list of red flags. The list is not complete, but several items apply to any online supplier:
- The buyer is reluctant to share information about how the product will be used.
- The product does not fit the buyer's line of business.
- The buyer has little or no business background.
- The buyer is evasive about whether the product is for domestic use or for export or reexport.
- A freight forwarder is listed as the final destination.
- The shipping route is unusual for the product and destination, or the packaging does not match the stated shipping method or destination.
- Delivery dates are vague, or delivery is to an out-of-the-way location.
BIS's guidance says that when red flags appear, you should look into the circumstances and ask about the end use, end user and destination. If the concerns cannot be explained, BIS says you should either refrain from the transaction or submit the relevant information to BIS. It also warns against cutting off the flow of information that reaches your business in the normal course of work, for example by telling sales staff not to ask about end use.
Building export checks into your order process
- Keep a product classification record and recheck it when you add products or BIS updates the CCL.
- Keep a destination list of countries you do not ship to and enforce it at checkout and in fulfillment. Shipping restrictions by destination explains how.
- Screen the parties on international orders, including any consignee or forwarder, and record the result.
- Ask about end use and end user where your process calls for it. A research-use declaration at checkout is a self-declaration by the buyer. It does not resolve a red flag on its own.
- Hold orders that raise questions until a named person has reviewed them. Authorize now, capture later describes how order holds work.
- Keep records of the classification, screening results, questions asked, answers received and the decision.
Claddr's buyer checks compare buyer type, credentials and ship-to against your compliance profile, and rules you write in plain terms can hold matching orders, authorized but not captured, until a reviewer on your team approves them. The audit record stores each check and decision against the order. These checks are not export classification or restricted party screening, and those decisions stay with you and your advisers.
What this page cannot tell you
This page cannot tell you whether a particular product is controlled, whether a shipment needs a license or whether an exception applies. Those answers depend on your products, destinations and buyers. BIS's guidance includes contact points for exporters with questions, and a qualified lawyer, licensed customs broker or trade compliance specialist can review your specific situation.
Sources
- 01BIS: Classify your itemwww.bis.gov/licensing/classify-your-item
- 02BIS: About Licensingwww.bis.gov/licensing
- 03BIS: Guidance on end-user and end-use controls and U.S. person controlswww.bis.gov/licensing/guidance-on-end-user-and-end-use-controls-and-us-person-controls
- 04BIS: "Know Your Customer" Guidance and Red Flagswww.bis.gov/node/1533
- 05BIS: What is a reexport?www.bis.gov/articles/what-reexport