A refund is something you choose to send. A dispute is something the cardholder's bank starts. When an order was placed by mistake, is no longer wanted, or is one you would refund anyway, refunding before the buyer goes to their bank usually costs you less and keeps you in control of the outcome.
Stripe states that customers cannot dispute fully refunded payments. It also states that once a dispute is open, you cannot issue a refund outside the dispute process. So the timing matters: the choice between a refund and a dispute usually has to be made before the dispute exists.
What happens when you refund
Stripe's refund documentation sets out how refunds work:
- You can refund all or part of a payment after it succeeds. Stripe says the processing fees from the original transaction are not returned.
- Refunds are paid from your available Stripe balance.
- Refunds can only go back to the original payment method. You cannot send a refund to a different card or bank account.
- The buyer usually sees the credit about 5 to 10 business days later, depending on their bank. Refunds issued shortly after the charge may appear as a reversal instead, where the original charge drops off the statement.
- A payment that has been authorized but not captured is not refunded. It is canceled, and Stripe says canceling a payment before it is completed has no cost.
What happens when a buyer disputes
Stripe's description of a dispute is quite different:
- Stripe debits the disputed amount plus a dispute fee from your balance. For most businesses, and unless your Stripe contract says otherwise, Stripe does not return the fee for receiving a dispute, even if you win.
- If you counter the dispute, a separate dispute countered fee applies, which Stripe returns if you win.
- Your dispute rate with that card network goes up.
- You usually have 7 to 21 days to respond, depending on the network, and the full process can take 2 to 3 months.
- The outcome is decided by the cardholder's bank, not by you or Stripe.
Stripe also notes that card networks look at how many disputes you receive, not how many you win or lose. A dispute you win still counts. Our page on dispute rates explains why that number matters.
Why refunding first is usually better
For a payment you are sure is fraud, Stripe recommends refunding immediately, unless a liability shift such as 3D Secure covers it. Doing so saves the dispute fee, the increase to your dispute rate and the possible loss of product. The same logic applies to ordinary order problems. Common cases where an early refund or cancellation makes sense:
- A duplicate charge. Stripe advises correcting duplicates immediately and telling the buyer you have handled it.
- An order you will not fulfill. If you decide not to ship, for example because the buyer could not be verified or the order did not fit your terms of sale, cancel or refund it promptly rather than leaving the payment in place.
- A buyer who asks for a refund your policy allows. Stripe recommends honoring your written policies promptly when a customer is entitled to a refund.
- A payment you suspect is fraud, before shipping. Stripe says a more aggressive refund approach can make sense when the order has not yet been fulfilled, because a refund can then prevent the loss of your product.
Stripe also lists situations where refunding suspicious payments more readily can make sense: recent dispute activity that is excessive by card network definitions, already being in a chargeback monitoring program, or being a new or small business where one or two disputes can have an outsized effect on your rate.
Partial refunds can still be disputed
A partial refund does not close off a dispute. Stripe states that customers can dispute partially refunded payments, and that card network rules even allow a partially refunded payment to be disputed for the full amount.
If that happens, Stripe recommends always responding. Include the amount and date of the partial refund, and a screenshot of the refund in your Dashboard. Stripe calls this a credit issued response.
When a dispute is already open
Once a dispute is open, the rules change:
- You cannot refund outside the dispute. Stripe says you cannot issue a refund outside the dispute process while the dispute is open.
- A pending refund may fail. If a buyer disputes while a refund is still pending, the refund can fail. Stripe recommends accepting or challenging the dispute instead of refunding, to avoid paying the buyer twice.
- Accept rather than ask for a withdrawal. If you agree the buyer should keep the money, Stripe recommends accepting the dispute rather than asking the cardholder to withdraw it in exchange for a regular refund. Stripe says accepting is not an admission of wrongdoing, though the dispute fee still applies.
- If you had already refunded, say so. Proof that you compensated the customer before they opened the dispute is evidence Stripe lists as helping to show a dispute is invalid.
- Inquiries can still be settled. Some networks send an inquiry before a formal dispute. Stripe says you can resolve an inquiry without a dispute fee by providing satisfactory evidence or issuing a full refund.
For how the rest of the process works, see disputes and chargebacks basics.
Refund to the original payment method only
Stripe states that refunds can only be sent back to the original payment method used in a charge. If the card has expired or been canceled, Stripe says the card issuer handles the refund and in most cases credits the buyer's replacement card. Treat any request to send a refund some other way, such as by check or wire to a different account, with caution, and keep the refund on the card that paid.
Deciding before you capture
The cheapest refund is the one you never need. Stripe notes that cardholders cannot dispute uncaptured authorizations, only captured payments, and that canceling an uncaptured payment has no cost. That is the case for reviewing orders between authorization and capture, covered in our guide to authorize-now, capture-later order holds.
With Claddr, orders that match rules the merchant writes are authorized but not captured until a reviewer on the merchant's team approves them, so an order your team decides not to fulfill has not been captured yet. Whatever tools you use, write down why each refund or cancellation was made. Your refund and return policy should say when buyers can expect one.
Sources
- 01Stripe Docs: Refund and cancel paymentsdocs.stripe.com/refunds
- 02Stripe Docs: How disputes workdocs.stripe.com/disputes/how-disputes-work
- 03Stripe Docs: Best practices for preventing frauddocs.stripe.com/disputes/prevention/best-practices
- 04Stripe Docs: Dispute evidence best practicesdocs.stripe.com/disputes/best-practices
- 05Stripe Docs: Dispute reason code categoriesdocs.stripe.com/disputes/categories